| 1. | STEMEN, Henry | (1775-1855) | Minister 1809-? | Bishop 1820-1855 |
| 2. | GOOD, John | ( ? - ? ) | Minister 1809-? | |
| 3. | STEMEN, Peter | (1771-1844) | Deacon 1809-? | |
| 5. | BRENNEMAN, John M. | (1816-1895) | Minister 1844-1848 | Bishop 1849-1855 |
| 6. | BRENNEMAN, George | (1816-1895) | Minister 1852-1853 | Bishop 1854- |
| 7. | BRENNEMAN, Daniel | (1834-1919) | Minister 1857-1864 | |
| 4. | STEMEN, Nicholas | (1802-1878) | Deacon 1858-1878 | Property deeded to Stemen and Successors |
| 8. | BEERY, Christian | (1831 -1900) | Deacon 1865-1866 | |
| 9. | BRENNEMAN, Noah | (1831-1914) | Deacon 1865-1866 | |
| 10. | BRENNEMAN, Henry D. | (1831-1887) | Deacon 1865-1866 | |
| 11. | HUBER, Benjamin | (1830-1907) | Deacon ~1855-1869 | Minister 1870-1907 |
| 12. | STEMEN, Nicholas | (1829-1896) | Deacon 1887-? | |
| 13. | BEERY, Daniel F. | (1842-1911) | Deacon ? - ? | |
| 14. | STOLZFUS, Ben B. | (1861-1931) | Minister 1907-1909 | |
| 15. | GOOD, Jacob A. | (1872-1945) | Minister 1915-1945 | |
| 16. | DETWEILER, Roy | (1898-1980) | Deacon 1939-1955 | |
| 17. | MILLER, William A. | (1897-1970) | Minister 1945-1955 | |
| 18. | WESSELHOEFT, Carl J. | (1929-2023) | Minister 1955-2004 | Mission service in Somalia - 1955-1966; TRMC - 1966-2004 |
| 19. | GOOD, Marion E. | (1922-1997) | Minister 1956-1963 | |
| 20. | BRUNK, Norman | (1924-1987) | Deacon 1958-1963 | |
| 21. | PLANK, Donald W. | (1928-2021) | Minister 1964-1967 | |
| 22. | FISHER, Robert J. | (1952- ) | Minister 1976-2016 | Overseer - 2017-present |
| 23. | BENDER, J. Michael | (1958- ) | Minister 2002-present | |
| 24. | SMITH, Todd A. | (1973- ) | Minister 2020-present | Ordination transferred in as Minister of Evangelism |
| 25. | MILLER, James | (1964- ) | Minister 2023-present | |